Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 
©2009 *manga-ai
:iconmanga-ai:

Artist's Comments

siiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiigh


I worked sooo hard on this. and put in sooo much effort.

And it's crap D:

Critiques


:iconpink-princess893:
As promised I'll try to write a critique for this ^^ It'll be the first time I've ever tried to critique anything so... Yeah, I'll try to make what I'm saying understandable as opposed to just some random rambling only me or someone very much like me could understand.

Okay, first thing's first. I really like the clothing folds, you're so good at them, they could probably be enhanced a bit by some shading though :D;

The first thing about this that I really saw as a flaw would be the green haired girls left(?) arm. It kinda seems like it has a dent in it. If you ask me I think the dent-ish bit (sorry if you can't understand what I'm saying) should be facing towards her body and be a bit smaller.

The girls left leg also kind of bothers me. It seems like she has her knee slightly bent and it's broken or oddly shaped or something. That could be remedied by moving the part not covered by the jeans to the right or by changing the angle so that part of the leg points to the left more ^^

I really like the dripping water, though in some places it seems to defy gravity a little (presuming she's somehow moving upwards and to the right), such as on some parts of the green haired girls hair.

Speaking of the green haired girls hair, what exactly is going on with it? o.o It kind or seems like she had a head band on but it's started falling off. I can't seem to work out if that was what you intended it to be of if it's been put up with a hair tie or what's going on with it ^^; And part of the shine on her hair ends before her hair does.

I like the blue haired girls hair. There's just something about it I really like, though I cant put my finger on what o.o I do kinda think the sword she's holding is a little thick though. And that her leg (the one furthest right) gets a little bit too small.

To me the clouds seem a little off ^^; They don't quite seem as fluffy as realistic-ish clouds, but at the same time they're not solid as cartoon-ish clouds.

Also, I don't know why but I think this should have a small black border o.o I honestly have no idea why ^^;

Okay, I think that's all :D
The Artist thought this was FAIR
4 out of 4 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconthedarkninjawarrior:
its not crap..
>.> but u spelled water wrong just saying >.>

--
"bye lulu.. your my hero!!hehe smile again please.. be happy..ill speak with you later my hero"That keeps me smiling everyday----My best friend Alex(girl<3)----
--
*GBSTA
:iconmanga-ai:
if ya say so luisa and I did?
:iconrozalynd:
WOAH THIS LOOKS SO COOL <3

--
I obsess over my own characters because no one else will. *huggles them and spams you with fanart of them* x3
:iconpink-princess893:
I just feel like leaving a comment because my friends are asleep :D;

Anywho, I like it :meow: *shot*

Also, long critique for a long time ago is long o.o; How did I manage it? ...Bet it makes not sense >.<;

--
...I'm going to regret that aren't I?
---
IDEA, IDEA, IDEA! X3
If you critique me you get a request!
---
[link] <--- The Sector E forum x3
---
Art trades, collaborations and commission are open XD
:iconthedarkninjawarrior:
well before you did >.>

--
"bye lulu.. your my hero!!hehe smile again please.. be happy..ill speak with you later my hero"That keeps me smiling everyday----My best friend Alex(girl<3)----
--
*GBSTA
:iconmanga-ai:
um idk lemme read it
:iconmanga-ai:
oh yeah i fixed it
:iconthedarkninjawarrior:
I could tell

--
"bye lulu.. your my hero!!hehe smile again please.. be happy..ill speak with you later my hero"That keeps me smiling everyday----My best friend Alex(girl<3)----
--
*GBSTA

Details

October 29
598 KB
598 KB
500×760

Statistics

12
4 [who?]
56 (0 today)
2 (0 today)

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map